FRONTPAGE| 3D| ART| BERLIN| BOOKS| COMICS| COMPUTING| DEUTSCHLAND| GAMES| HISTORY| MEDIA| MOVIES| MUSIC| MUTANTEN| PEOPLE| PLACES| POLITICS| POPCULTURE| PRODUCTS| SCIENCE| TV | WRITING

Thursday, 10. March 2005

MEDIA:

Is journalism the first draft of history?

Interesting column by Brett Stephens of The Wall Street Journal Editorial Page:

"Remember Japan Inc.? If you were a semi-sentient consumer of news in the 1980s, it was hard to avoid the impression that Japan would soon overtake the U.S. in global economic clout, if its corporations didn't just purchase the country outright. They've got Rockefeller Center! They're gobbling up Hollywood! Chalmers Johnson, Clyde Prestowitz and other soi-disant experts pronounced sagely on the invincible Japanese model of industrial organization, while the media supplied a diet of stories about how companies such as Sony or Honda remained world-beaters, year-in and year-out.

Now consider the amazing media about-face in recent weeks on Iraq. Prior to Jan. 30, dateline Baghdad was dateline Götterdämmerung. Now it's dateline Democracy. Bombs are still exploding, but we aren't reading much anymore about how we're losing hearts and minds, or how Iraq is ethnically too fractious to have a meaningful democracy. Instead, the media connect the dots between elections in Baghdad and events in Beirut, Cairo and Ramallah, and talk about 1989.

(...) The cliché is that journalism is the first draft of history. Yet a historian searching for clues about the origins of many of the great stories of recent decades--the collapse of the Soviet empire; the rise of Osama bin Laden; the declining American crime rate; the economic eclipse of Japan and Germany--would find most contemporary journalism useless. Perhaps a story here or there might, in retrospect, seem illuminating. But chances are it would have been nearly invisible at the time of publication: eight column inches, page A12.

The problem is not that journalists can't get their facts straight: They can and usually do. Nor is it that the facts are obscure: Often, the most essential facts are also the most obvious ones. The problem is that journalists have a difficult time distinguishing significant facts--facts with consequences--from insignificant ones. That, in turn, comes from not thinking very hard about just which stories are most worth telling.

(...) Look for the countervailing data. Broaden your list of sources. Beware of exoticizing your subject: If you think that Israelis and Palestinians operate from no higher motive than revenge, you're on the wrong track. Above all, never forget the obvious: that the law of supply and demand operates in Japan, too; that the Soviet Union was a state governed by fear; that Iraqis aren't rooting for their killers; that, if given the chance, people will choose to be free.


ID - Stefan Ernsting - I have two books out, I work on cool movies and I've been blogging for 7976 days.

SUBSCRIBE TO BLOG | BOOKMARK BLOG

 

REGISTER OR LOGIN HERE!

dancing wookie
... Home
... Tags

New Stories & Comments
TOM censored
by tommyblank (10/1/10, 10:08 AM)
New York im Schnelldurchlauf -
Grosser Apfel mit Stellen Aus aktuellem Anlass und weil zahlreiche...
by tommyblank (8/18/09, 12:24 PM)
Sorry, this blog has moved!
Wait for the orientation videos over at my Homepage or...
by tommyblank (7/26/09, 3:24 PM)
READ ME FIRST! This blog
had many technical problems this year and it doesn't look...
by tommyblank (7/26/09, 3:03 PM)
THE NEW BLOG IS OPEN!
Over at popmoderne.wordpress.com! Tränen, Danksagungen, Kommentar zur Zukunft von Antville...
by -stern- (1/26/09, 7:24 PM)
WATCH MORE COOL DOCUMENTARIES FOR
FREE Harry says: "Our friends at Cinetic Media are doing...
by -stern- (1/10/09, 2:53 PM)

FILMS I WORKED ON


Chew the Fat (2008)

Photobucket
The Science of Horror (2008)


The Red Elvis (2007)

BÜCHER

DER PHANTASTISCHE REBELL ALEXANDER MORITZ FREY oder Hitler schießt dramatisch in die Luft
(Atrium Verlag, Februar 2007)

Info & Pressestimmen (PDF)

Vorabdruck bei Perlentaucher

A.M. Frey auf MySpace!

DER ROTE ELVIS oder Das kuriose Leben eines US-Rockstars in der DDR
(Aufbau Verlag/Gustav Kiepenheuer)

Der rote Elvis

Taschenbuch (7,95 € / 14,80 Sfr /3-7466-2261-1)

(Hardcover, 314 Seiten, 34 Abbildungen, 22,50 €)

Info & Pressestimmen (PDF)

English Info

Übersetzung:
David Wojnarowicz
Closes to the Knives

(Mox und Maritz Verlag)

"Von Stefan Ernsting hervorragend übersetzt." (Bayrischer Rundfunk))

Leseprobe

Blog Top Liste - by TopBlogs.de

RSS Feed

Last update: 1/4/11, 9:56 AM

Made with Antville